Rebecca Cantwell, CO SEIA Executive Director, about settling with Xcel and moving solar forward

Rebecca Cantwell is the Executive Director of COSEIA, one of the best State level trade associations. Rebecca has been the director for 5 years and brought COSEIA through a multitude of regulatory issues. With a small budget of about $250,000, COSEIA brings results in a true David versus Goliath fight. COSEIA is an independent entity. It may be listed as an affiliated partner, COSEIA does not report to or receive funding from SEIA. This is a separation that has been made clear to SolarWakeup by many State SEIA groups. Most recently, COSEIA was in the room where it happens. Negotiating with Xcel Energy in Colorado has been a nearly yearlong effort. Through many full days of sitting in Xcel conference rooms, COSEIA was an intervenor in all three solar related dockets. The group came to a settlement which had some positive effects which Rebecca covers in great specificity in our conversation. What struck me is that even though COSEIA was an intervenor, SEIA also deployed resources by intervening in two of the dockets. That means COSEIA and SEIA were duplicating efforts, representing their own memberships. I would see it more effective to send capital to the State and align the interests of both SEIA entities. In the coming weeks, we will be speaking with more State level directors on how the State level chapters are driving their markets forward. If you enjoyed this episode as much as I did, make sure to subscribe on your favorite podcast platform including iTunes, SoundCloud and Stitcher radio. Please subscribe and share with your friends how much EnergyWakeup is helping you! [soundcloud id='320989248' height='false']

This is your SolarWakeup for May 4th, 2017

Seeing the bigger picture. I was pretty upset at Suniva last week. I’ve spent my days and nights looking at the filings, speaking to experts and trying to understand the various issues. When it came down to it, Suniva didn’t have a choice. Either they shut the door and walked away or took the chapter 11 money. From a fiduciary standpoint, I don’t think employees had a choice. SQN was the available lender and their caveat was filing the 201 petition. I am certain that given the choice, Suniva would have chosen an alternative path. As I continue my work, I need to hear from you and your ideas. We have to look at every opportunity to stop the petition to help our industry. This is an issue to affects us all, do not ignore this. At the very least look at your projects and change your module assumption to a $0.78/watt price and tell me what it does for you.
Tax Free Florida. Voters in Florida overwhelmingly voted to pass a tax exemption for commercial solar, fixing a mistake from a constitutional amendment voted on 10 years ago. The bill isn’t perfect, hasn’t left the legislature and it isn’t signed by the Governor but it looks promising. Baby steps, one foot in front of another, or whatever metaphor you like.
Are you offering storage for your solar projects in California? I want to hear from you. In the near future, I will be doing a learning tour and meeting with contractors and developers throughout California working in and around energy storage. 
Utilities versus IPPs. There is a circuit including talking points in the wholesale markets. IPPs have been speaking at energy conferences and they are not happy with the zero emission credits given to nuclear power plant operators. Specifically Dynegy believes that the ZECs given to Exelon in Illinois is a bailout that will cause the markets to stop functioning because it absorbs the valuable capacity value. It’s happened at two conferences that I read about, we shall see if it happens again.
Make sure you listen to the latest episodes of EnergyWakeup. Hear from solar entrepreneur, John Gurski, the founder of Energy Toolbase, a cloud based energy bill analytics and proposal tool. I also speak with Tony Clifford from Standard Solar about being acquired by Gaz Metro and his work at SEIA.

News

 

Have a great day!
Yann

This is your SolarWakeup for May 3rd, 2017

Would you be angry? I wonder how I would handle the situation. Imagine driving a vision for a massive company that changes the path it is on, a pivot but not in a startup. Public companies are impatient and creating the new path gets you fired. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not shy and have been known to rock a boat or two but this takes major guts. After getting fired, a few quarters go by, and the company realizes you were right. A few years pass and the company is executing on your original vision because it was the right financial play. Do you sit and smile about being correct? Beat yourself up for rocking the boat? Or get angry for being fired and saying I told you so? Annoying if you ask me but NRG is an interesting case study for leadership in public companies.
Influencing the policy. We covered Thomas Pyle, the former transition chair for DOE. Now one of his former employees is taking over as the acting head for EERE. Why? To pretty much do the opposite of and undo the work of the Obama administration. EERE covers a lot of solar related activities and improves job opportunities across America, including job training, education and empowering regulations. Dan Simmons is the man you will hear about today and going forward regarding EERE matters.
Are you offering storage for your solar projects in California? I want to hear from you. In the near future, I will be doing a learning tour and meeting with contractors and developers throughout California working in and around energy storage. 
As goes Ohio? The solar industry in Indiana was hoping that they could get the Governor to veto an anti-net metering bill that the legislature passed. Unfortunately that wasn’t a successful venture. This is politics and the market wasn’t big enough to pressure the Governor into making the right decision. That being said, I’m always disappointed that a reporter transcribes the utility talking points when they are so obviously untrue.
Make sure you listen to the latest episodes of EnergyWakeup. Hear from solar entrepreneur, John Gurski, the founder of Energy Toolbase, a cloud based energy bill analytics and proposal tool. I also speak with Tony Clifford from Standard Solar about being acquired by Gaz Metro and his work at SEIA.

News

 

Have a great day!
Yann

This is your SolarWakeup for May 2nd, 2017

Anyone have $4million to spare? The politics of this 201 petition are circular. Let’s recap. SQN Capital is the bankruptcy lender. In further reading the first motions by Suniva’s CRO, SQN is offering $4million through the bankruptcy. The loan is at 12% per year plus some fees and has the first lien security. I find the interest rate rather cheap given the circumstance which raises a red flag but let’s ignore for now. We need some allies in defeating the petition. First off, the Chinese modules makers should buy the debt from SQN right now on the condition of withdrawing the 201 petition. The cheapest $4million market entry price ever. Second, the utilities across America are going to have a problem. A $0.78/watt minimum price is going to significantly reduce the amount of solar they can ratebase. EEI must be hearing from its members on this topic, what will they do?
Defining Climate Change. I didn’t read the NY Times oped on climate change. The headline was annoying and I don’t feel like losing time reading a skeptics dissertation. That being said, we need to stop talking climate change. It doesn’t poll well, it’s partisan and too complicated to argue with skeptics. How do you convince someone gravity exists if they don’t believe it? We need to change the conversation. Clean water, clean air and solar energy. We all like that, we all want that. You can live in deep red States and your neighbors will be pro-solar and want to breath clean air. March for Science and Climate Change was great, for our echo-chamber but it leaves many outside of the bubble wondering what the agenda is. Preach solar. That’s our coalition.
Are you offering storage for your solar projects in California? I want to hear from you. In the near future, I will be doing a learning tour and meeting with contractors and developers throughout California working in and around energy storage.
A budget deal. House negotiators have come to an agreement to keep the Government running through the fiscal year. Let’s just say that Trump isn’t getting his wish in gutting the EPA and DOE budgets for this year. This doesn’t mean that good things will come of the money, likely many programs will stall because of lack of staffing and effort. You can see more in coverage on the issue.
Make sure you listen to the latest episodes of EnergyWakeup. Hear from solar entrepreneur, John Gurski, the founder of Energy Toolbase, a cloud based energy bill analytics and proposal tool. I also speak with Tony Clifford from Standard Solar about being acquired by Gaz Metro and his work at SEIA.

News

 

Have a great day!
Yann

This is your SolarWakeup for May 1st, 2017

Happy SGIP Day. For many contractors across California today is an exciting day. The first window for SGIP funding is opening today, assumed to be fully allocated within minutes. Legislators in California have gone big in funding the incentive and they have thought it about it logically, similar to the CSI, SGIP will step down quickly. You would assume that the quickly dropping battery costs will keep up with the drops in incentive. Here is my question to California contractors. How did you choose your partner? Once you chose the battery architecture, i.e. Lithium Ion, how did you pick the rest of the system. The software? The power electronics? The manufacturers? This is going to be a big market and I am contemplating a road trip through California to learn how storage is affecting your business. More on the road trip soon.
Was it up to Suniva? Suniva first got into trouble financially in 2015, when module pricing was much higher. That is when Shunfeng came in and acquired 63% of the company. More recently, as money was running out once again, Suniva had hired their former CFO, Jim Modak, as a consultant to raise more money. Modak had been the CFO for 8 years but left the company in March of 2016, staying on for 6 months as a consultant. Modak is now the CFO of SQN Capital Management. This is where it gets interesting. Shunfeng and Wanxiang were not willing to put in more capital into Suniva, forcing the company towards a Chapter 7 filing. One lender was willing to provide post-bankruptcy capital, SQN Capital, under certain conditions. The first condition was to file the 201 petition for a tariff. If Suniva wanted tariffs, they could have filed it a year ago, this seems to have been a requirement of SQN. I don’t know how much SQN is providing but it’s a financial play betting that Suniva assets are worth more if a minimum price is put into place.
Help support SolarWakeup. If you are looking for investors or buyers of your projects, hit reply to this email and let us help you. Our expansive network is always looking to partner with you and helps us pay the bills to keep the newsletter free to you, as it has been for the past 4 years.
The pension funds. Pension funds are playing in solar. They’ve long circled the wagons, waiting to see if scale is there to make an initial investment with enough room to follow on year after year. The consolidation of assets is also creating new market opportunities because unlike utilities, pension funds will likely outsource asset management, O&M and other functions. This also creates a nice value to investment bankers that specialize in the field like MVP Capital. Pension funds are lean operations and solar is likely to create outsized returns compared to asset classes like real estate.
Make sure you listen to the latest episodes of EnergyWakeup. Hear from solar entrepreneur, John Gurski, the founder of Energy Toolbase, a cloud based energy bill analytics and proposal tool. I also speak with Tony Clifford from Standard Solar about being acquired by Gaz Metro and his work at SEIA.

News

 

Have a great day!
Yann

This is your SolarWakeup for April 28th, 2017

All about Suniva. Today, I want to explain the Suniva situation in a simple enough way that you can take it to your mother, child’s teacher or neighbor. With the request for a minimum price of $0.78 cents, Suniva is trying to hurt the solar industry in a way that is worse than if the ITC had not been extended. Depending on your volume, your price will more than double for solar panels. Projects in markets that compete for PURPA contracts, like NC, UT, and OR, will increase their costs by 40% or more rendering the markets null. Massachusetts may have to delay their benchmark pricing auction for the SMART program because a $0.40 cent delta in installed pricing will cost the consumers in MA more money.
The irony of Suniva. The EVP of Suniva said this, “Without today’s requested global safeguard, the U.S. solar manufacturing industry will die and we will not only lose solar manufacturing jobs today, but also those future jobs that will come from investing in the solar manufacturing industry of tomorrow.” Looking at the comment, you have to laugh at the irony behind it. Suniva took in tens of millions in SunShot and other grants to build their R&D. Moreover, when Suniva made the move to invest $12.5million into a manufacturing plant in Michigan, Saginaw offered up $2.5million in grants to do that. This is not a global safeguard, this is a company annoyed that they lost. Not building out a dealer network and selling to Sunpower dealers was bad business that had nothing to do with cheap solar modules.
Why Trump would agree. Easy answer, The Koch Brothers. A Georgia based company that opened manufacturing in Michigan is going out of business because of cheap Chinese goods. That would be the talking point pushed into the public but we all know that it is false. The real reason would be that this is about the disruption it would cause to the solar industry which would be helpful for the adversaries that wish the industry harm. It is rumored that a 201 filing typically starts with a nod from an administration prior to filing which may likely have happened here.
Help support SolarWakeup. If you are looking for investors or buyers of your projects, hit reply to this email and let us help you. Our expansive network is always looking to partner with you and helps us pay the bills to keep the newsletter free to you, as it has been for the past 4 years.
Why Trump could and should say no. Jobs and China. The argument to say no to Suniva is that it would cost the solar industry and incredible number of jobs. The industry would drastically slow and more companies would go out of business. Interestingly, Suniva would still be bankrupt and would have a hard time getting off the ground again in a slowing market where most customers would shun them. So the jobs President would have to choose to kill jobs. Second, China. China could make this a big point in the ongoing conversations between the President of both Countries. Does Trump really want to hurt American jobs while also angering a central industry in China while he is looking to get China to help with North Korea? China has seen the impact of a minimum price in Europe and repeating that in the US would be disastrous given the total capacity of manufacturing in the Country.
Make sure you listen to the latest episodes of EnergyWakeup. Hear from solar entrepreneur, John Gurski, the founder of Energy Toolbase, a cloud based energy bill analytics and proposal tool. I also speak with Tony Clifford from Standard Solar about being acquired by Gaz Metro and his work at SEIA.

News

 

Have a great day!
Yann

This is your SolarWakeup for April 27th, 2017

Holy Shit, Suniva. Last week I told you I liked many of the folks at Suniva. So to my friends still at the company. GET THE HELL OUT OF THERE! Suniva made a bad business decision in opening a factory in Michigan at the wrong time. Keep in mind that Suniva has long been arguing that SolarWorld’s trade cases have impacted their module assembly in Asia. Now the company owned by Shunfeng, which also owns Suntech wants to destroy the US solar industry. In reality, Suniva just handed the Trump administration the perfect way to do just that. The Koch Brothers are popping champagne bottles right now, a ‘China is playing unfair’, talking point will be the populist agenda covering up the desire to hurt US energy consumers across the Country. Suniva should be ashamed of itself instead of this ridiculous attempt to take everyone else down with them.
Storage keeps moving. California is moving forward with energy storage. The State will lead once again as the customers transition to NEM 2.0 and most customers go to time of use with demand charge schedules. I will have some announcements about my work in this space soon. If you are involved in developing storage projects, let me know so I can let you know personally about the work I will be involved in.
Help support SolarWakeup. If you are looking for investors or buyers of your projects, hit reply to this email and let us help you. Our expansive network is always looking to partner with you and helps us pay the bills to keep the newsletter free to you, as it has been for the past 4 years.
My comments from yesterday. I feel pretty strongly about what I said yesterday. If you missed it, I said that BNEF should not have invited Rick Perry to speak at their summit. I heard from many of you, both agreeing and disagreeing with me. My point is simple, Perry had the solar delegation in his office a few weeks ago. This was a one-way conversation and not a pitch on what renewable energy can do for America. So why put him in a room that would groan and shake their heads at his comments. If we want to impact change, let’s get away from the politicians and focus on the people. That’s who we should be pitching and educating. People fire Congressman, not trade associations or conference participants. People have the power.
Make sure you listen to the latest episodes of EnergyWakeup. Hear from solar entrepreneur, John Gurski, the founder of Energy Toolbase, a cloud based energy bill analytics and proposal tool. I also speak with Tony Clifford from Standard Solar about being acquired by Gaz Metro and his work at SEIA.

News

 

Have a great day!
Yann

This is your SolarWakeup for April 26th, 2017

Old Data, New Coverage. We’ve seen the DOE Energy Employment Report already, the data is positive and friendly to the energy sector. That being said, the New York Times is doing a nice infographic on the data given the President’s focus on the energy sector. It also needs to be repeated because the quantity of solar jobs doesn’t appear to really hit home with all politicians quite yet, many of them still consider solar jobs subsidized and temporary.
Flip it and reverse it. I can’t even, I don’t know, I mean, oops. I know Rick Perry is the Secretary of Energy but he has no business getting an audience at a conference like BNEF. It does nothing more than incite uncertainty and fear as opposed to real policy discussions. Renewables driving more coal? Nuclear weapons depend on new nuclear power plants? Give me a break. BNEF is better than this, and if they insist on having him speak, should counter program the speech with people that can rebut the nonsense immediately. ERCOT is showing the the Country how competitive RTOs drive the cost down and provide consumers with choice on source and price.
Help support SolarWakeup. If you are looking for investors or buyers of your projects, hit reply to this email and let us help you. Our expansive network is always looking to partner with you and helps us pay the bills to keep the newsletter free to you, as it has been for the past 4 years.
Lowering soft costs. What is the real soft cost of solar power? How much are you putting it into your estimates for non-hardware and non-labor costs? As we transition to time of use, energy storage and more complicated analysis, I am concerned to hear that most of the industry is still relying on excel files for rate analysis and production analysis. I heard this in my conversation with Energy Toolbase CEO and many of the CEOs at the asset management summit. Excel files are costing you money and projects, time to transition to software solutions and get more efficient.
Make sure you listen to the latest episodes of EnergyWakeup. Hear from solar entrepreneur, John Gurski, the founder of Energy Toolbase, a cloud based energy bill analytics and proposal tool. I also speak with Tony Clifford from Standard Solar about being acquired by Gaz Metro and his work at SEIA.

News

 

Have a great day!
Yann

This is your SolarWakeup for April 25th, 2017

Using Data For Policy. One of the topics of conversation with John Gurski, the founder and CEO of Energy Toolbase, was policy. Given the database of utility rates and the ability to model savings based on a example demand structure, Energy Toolbase can and has shown what the potential impact on solar consumers is if a proposed rate design structure is implemented. This kind of simple, results oriented data point speaks to people in a way that rate design proceedings often misses. If you are involved in a policy debate, use the value of solar’s popularity by showing the results of policy.
Coal’s exes live in Texas. The City of Houston has signed a PPA to buy the energy from a 50MW solar farm in Texas. Let the reality of the oil capital going solar sink in and realize that this is purely an economic transaction. Engie, the developer, has its US headquarters there and used to be a large IPP in the US as well. Now, Engie has sold its assets and is focused on a diverse set of cleantech investments and retail energy. Competition works, and you can compare Florida and Texas as two ways to achieve that, one with an open market and one with monopolies.
Help support SolarWakeup. If you are looking for investors or buyers of your projects, hit reply to this email and let us help you. Our expansive network is always looking to partner with you and helps us pay the bills to keep the newsletter free to you, as it has been for the past 4 years.
No Comment from me, I want yours. I read the Bloomberg article about SEIA’s comments at BNEF with intrigue. I have some thoughts but I want to hear yours. Hit reply and let me know what you think.
Make sure you listen to the latest episodes of EnergyWakeup. Hear from solar entrepreneur, John Gurski, the founder of Energy Toolbase, a cloud based energy bill analytics and proposal tool. I also speak with Tony Clifford from Standard Solar about being acquired by Gaz Metro and his work at SEIA.

News

 

Have a great day!
Yann

John Gurski, Founder and CEO of Energy Toolbase, a solar startup creating a smarter proposal

This week I spent time with John Gurski, the young and hungry CEO of Energy Toolbase. While I was familiar with Energy Toolbase COO, Adam Gerza, I had not met John yet and was surprised to find out he was based in South Florida. So I made the drive to join him and some of his team at their offices. John has spent time as a solar developer, pitching clients and working on roofs. It was 2012 when he came up with the problem, how can you create a better proposal for customers without having to copy and paste inside an excel file. The only problem was, he didn’t know how to code. So like any reasonable solar developer, he taught himself. Launching in 2014, John convinced his fiancée, now his wife, and his father to man the startup alley booth for the newly founded Energy Toolbase booth at Intersolar NA. With initial clients signed up, the company was off to a big start. Now the team is over a dozen, 3 offices and revenue in the millions. Energy Toolbase has taken the proposal tool further by integrating sophisticated rate analysis and a robust database of utility rates. The team scours the utility rate schedules and updates them for their users on an ongoing basis. Coming soon is the complete overhaul of their storage analysis platform. With the ability to either upload 8760 data or create a simulated version based on energy bills, contractors and developers will be able to model demand reduction, demand shifting and demand arbitrage with the new release. I love spending time with startup founders that choose solar over other fields. Energy Toolbase is a success story and they have not raised any money, yet. If you enjoyed this episode as much as I did, make sure to subscribe on your favorite podcast platform including iTunes, SoundCloud and Stitcher radio. Please subscribe and share with your friends how much EnergyWakeup is helping you! [soundcloud id='319165659' height='false']